Binggrae Together Ice Cream vs Natuur: Korean Tub Battle

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

The Late-Night Seoul Freezer Aisle Dilemma

It was 11:30 PM on a humid July night in Seoul when I walked into the GS25 right outside my apartment building, desperately looking for something cold to beat the summer heat. The clerk barely looked up as the automatic doors slid open. I headed straight for the glass-topped freezer chest in the back, sliding open the door to reveal rows of brightly colored ice cream bars, cones, and tubs. On one side sat the iconic gold-and-red tub of binggrae together ice cream, a mainstay of Korean homes since 1974. On the other sat Natuur, Lotte’s sleek, premium competitor designed to rival high-end Western ice cream brands.

If you walk into any convenience store or neighborhood supermarket in Korea, you will see these two brands competing for freezer space. While single-serve bars like Melona and Samanco get all the viral hype on social media, tub ice cream is what locals buy when they want a late-night dessert on the couch or a sweet base for homemade desserts. International K-food fans often wonder: is the nostalgic Binggrae Together worth buying over the pricier Natuur, or should you shell out the extra cash for Lotte’s luxury tub? I bought both, grabbed two spoons, and tested them side-by-side to bring you the definitive review.

The Contenders: Taste, Texture, and Local Hacks

Binggrae Together Vanilla: The Nostalgic Korean Classic

First up is the undisputed monarch of Korean family desserts: Binggrae Together Vanilla. Binggrae launched this product in 1974 as Korea’s first domestic ice cream made from pure raw milk, breaking into a market previously dominated by water-based popsicles. The vintage aesthetic of the tub has barely changed over the decades, making it immediately recognizable to anyone who grew up in Korea.

Flavor and Profile: When you open the lid, you are greeted by a soft, pale cream color. The flavor profile of binggrae together ice cream is clean, smooth, and light. Unlike heavy American vanilla ice creams that hit you with intense vanilla extract or visible vanilla bean flecks, Together tastes primarily like fresh milk with a gentle, comforting vanilla sweetness. It is not overly sugary, nor is it buttery or dense. It leaves a very clean finish on your palate without any coat-your-mouth film.

Texture: Extremely airy, soft, and easy to scoop right out of the freezer. You do not need to let this tub sit on the counter for ten minutes before plunging your spoon into it. The high whipped air content gives it a pillow-like texture that melts quickly on your tongue.

Spice Level Comparison: 0/10. It features zero heat and is infinitely milder than a bowl of Shin Ramyun or Buldak 2x Spicy Noodle. In fact, its gentle dairy sweetness makes it the absolute best emergency cooldown tool in your freezer after eating a fiery bowl of Korean spicy noodles!

How Koreans Actually Eat It: Nobody in Korea eats Binggrae Together just straight from the tub anymore. It is famous for being the ultimate dessert building block. The most popular local hack is placing a massive scoop of Together on top of a hot, freshly toasted croffle (croissant waffle) or a warm brown-sugar hotteok (pancake). Another viral trend is topping traditional Korean syrup-soaked mini yakgwa pastries with a spoonful of Together. The cold, creamy milk flavor balances out the warm, sticky honey-syrup spices perfectly. Local coffee lovers also pour a fresh shot of hot espresso directly over a scoop to make a quick home cafe affogato.

Natuur Vanilla & Green Tea: The Premium Challenger

Natuur is Lotte’s premium ice cream brand, launched to compete directly with imported giants like Häagen-Dazs and Baskin Robbins. While Binggrae Together appeals to family comfort and nostalgia, Natuur positions itself as an indulgent treats brand aimed at adults and specialized dessert lovers.

Flavor and Profile: Natuur offers several flavors, but their Vanilla and Green Tea (Matcha) are the flagship tub offerings. The vanilla version uses rich milk solids and natural vanilla flavoring, resulting in a much deeper, custardy egg-and-vanilla taste compared to Binggrae. The Green Tea flavor is famous across Korea for using high-grade green tea powder, delivering a deeply savory, slightly bitter matcha punch offset by rich cream.

Texture: Dense, heavy, and velvety. When you dive your spoon into a tub of Natuur, you feel immediate resistance. It contains significantly less whipped air than Together, offering a decadent milk-fat creaminess that melts slowly in your mouth.

Spice Level Comparison: 0/10 heat, though the Green Tea flavor carries a distinct, pleasant grassy bitterness that contrasts sharply with standard sweet ice creams.

How Koreans Actually Eat It: Natuur is treated as an end-of-week reward dessert. People usually scoop it into fancy glassware, sprinkle matcha powder or chocolate shavings on top, and eat it slowly while watching late-night K-dramas. The Green Tea tub is especially popular for making homemade green tea lattes by blending a few scoops with cold milk.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Feature	Binggrae Together	Lotte Natuur
Target Vibe	Nostalgic family staple	Indulgent premium treat
Flavor Profile	Light, clean fresh milk	Rich, dense, deep vanilla/matcha
Scoopability	Soft and easy instantly	Dense, needs 2-3 mins soften
Price Range	~6,000 – 8,000 KRW	~10,000 – 13,000 KRW

Note: Prices vary depending on neighborhood discount ice cream shops (Aiseukeurim Halinjeom) versus convenience stores, where promotions like 1+1 or 2+1 buy-one-get-one deals change weekly.

How to Get It Abroad

If you live outside Korea, you do not have to fly to Seoul to try these tubs, though availability depends heavily on your local Korean grocery ecosystem.

• H Mart: Most major H Mart locations across the US, Canada, and Europe carry binggrae together ice cream in their frozen dessert aisles. It is usually stocked right next to Melona boxes. Natuur can occasionally be found in larger flagship H Mart locations, though Together is much more widely distributed.
• Local Asian Markets: Regional Korean grocers such as Zion Market, Hannam Chain, or 99 Ranch Market frequently stock Binggrae Together tubs. Look specifically in the Korean ice cream freezer chest rather than the general Asian novelty ice cream section.
• Online Asian Grocery Delivery: Platforms like Weee! often deliver frozen Korean items, including Binggrae Together, directly to your door in insulated dry-ice packaging if you reside within their delivery zones.

Verdict

If I could only keep one tub in my Seoul apartment freezer for the rest of the year, my vote goes to binggrae together ice cream. While Natuur unquestionably offers a richer, denser premium product akin to Western luxury brands, Binggrae Together represents the unique identity of Korean dairy desserts. Its light, clean milk taste makes it endlessly versatile for food hacks like topping hotteok, croffles, or espresso shots without overwhelming your palate with excess fat.

Binggrae Together Score: 9/10 – Unbeatable versatility, nostalgic comfort, light clean taste, and fantastic value for money.

Lotte Natuur Score: 7.5/10 – Deliciously rich and high quality, but pricier and less uniquely ‘Korean’ in taste compared to global premium brands.

FAQ

Is Binggrae Together ice cream gluten-free?

While the core ingredients of Binggrae Together Vanilla center on fresh milk and sugar, manufacturing facilities often process wheat-based snacks on shared lines. Always check the allergen warning label on the tub if you have celiac disease or severe gluten sensitivities.

Why is Binggrae Together so soft compared to Western tub ice cream?

Binggrae Together features a higher overrun (air whipped into the ice cream base) and uses fresh fluid milk combined with milk solids. This formulation keeps the texture fluffy and easy to scoop straight out of sub-zero freezers.

What is the best way to eat Binggrae Together ice cream like a local?

Pair a hot, toasted Korean waffle, croffle, or honey yakgwa pastry with a cold scoop of Together vanilla. The combination of warm, chewy dough with cold, melting milk ice cream is the absolute pinnacle of Korean cafe culture at home.

More Mart Finds

• Essential Korean Ice Popsicles & Frozen Treats
• Iconic Old Korean Ice Cream: Nostalgic Mart Finds
• Other Binggrae Ice Cream Gems Beyond Melona
• Korean Ice Cream Cones: A Sweet Guide to Popular Toppings & Flavors